how to choose the mechanical switch? - DIYKEY

how to choose the mechanical switch?

Choosing the right mechanical switch for your keyboard is a critical step in building or buying a mechanical keyboard. Switches significantly affect the typing feel and sound of the keyboard. Here’s a guide to help you choose the mechanical switch that best suits your needs:

Factors to Consider


1. Switch Type
Mechanical switches generally fall into three main categories:

Linear Switches: These have a smooth keystroke with no tactile bump or audible click. Ideal for fast typists and gamers.
Examples: kailh cardamom keyboard switch,Kailh Platycodon Grandiflorum Keyboard Switch

Tactile Switches: These feature a noticeable bump at the actuation point, providing tactile feedback.
Examples: Kailh Box Winter Switch

Clicky Switches: These provide both a tactile bump and an audible click at the actuation point.
Examples: Kailh Box Summer,Kailh Box Autumn Switch

2. Actuation Force
The force required to press a key and register a keystroke varies among switches. It’s measured in grams (g).

Light: ~35g to 45g (e.g., Cherry MX Red)
Medium: ~50g to 60g (e.g., Cherry MX Brown)
Heavy: 70g and above (e.g., Cherry MX Green)

3. Noise Level
Consider the environment where you’ll use the keyboard. If you need a quieter keyboard:

Opt for silent switches Kailh HUSH Deep Sea Switch Pro
Avoid clicky switches if noise is a concern.

4. Durability
Most mechanical switches are rated for a certain number of key presses (e.g., 50 million). Higher durability can mean a longer lifespan.

5. Application
Your primary use case can influence your switch choice:
Gaming: Linear switches are often preferred for their smooth and fast actuation.
Typing: Tactile switches provide feedback, which can be beneficial for typing.
Office Work: Silent or tactile switches are generally preferred to minimize noise.

6. Feel and Preference

Ultimately, personal preference plays a significant role. If possible, try out different switches in person or buy a switch tester to feel the differences.

Choosing the right mechanical switch involves understanding your preferences and needs. Here's a quick checklist to guide you:

Determine Your Primary Use: Gaming, typing, or office work.
Select Switch Type: Linear, tactile, or clicky.
Consider Actuation Force: Light, medium, or heavy.
Evaluate Noise Level: Silent, quiet, or clicky.

Comparison Table

Feature Kailh Box Winter (Tactile) Kailh Box Summer (Clicky) Kailh Spring (Linear) Whale Switch (Tactile)
Type Tactile Clicky Linear Tactile
Operating Force 40g 50g 50gf 45 + 10gf
Actuation Travel 2.0+0.4mm 1.8+0.4MM 1.8+0.4MM 2.0 + 0.4mm
Tactile Force 52GF+5GF 55+10GF 55+10GF 60 + 10gf
Total Travel 3.6+0.3mm 3.6+0.3mm 3.6+0.3mm 3.60 + 0.4mm
Tactile Bump Slight Obvious None Noticeable
Sound Quiet Clicky Low noise Quiet
Resistance Dust and water-resistant Dust and water-resistant Dust and water-resistant Dust and water-resistant
Ideal Use Typing and gaming Typing Gaming Typing and gaming
Noise Level Low High Low Low
Feedback Clear tactile feedback Strong tactile and auditory feedback Smooth and consistent actuation Clear tactile feedback
User Suitability Suitable for quiet environments and long-term use Suitable for those who enjoy strong feedback but not for quiet environments Suitable for fast key presses and long-term use without fatigue Suitable for accurate typing and gaming, comfortable for long-term use

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Leave a comment

All comments are moderated before being published.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.